It is clear that the federal government has jurisdiction over interprovincial pipelines, says letter writer. NEWS BULLETIN file

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Pipeline opposition is unconstitutional

This is just not a problem for B.C and Alberta; it is a problem for Canada, says letter writer.

To the editor,

Re: B.C., Alberta clash as Kinder Morgan suspends Trans Mountain work, April 8.

This is just not a problem for B.C and Alberta. It is a problem for Canada. And Canada’s constitution and the country as we know it. This is what is not highlighted enough.

It is clear that the federal government has jurisdiction over interprovincial pipelines. The trade and commerce clause, and the navigation clause makes this clear. And all existing interprovincial pipelines operate under federal jurisdiction. The Supreme Court of Canada has already ruled on such projects.

The Government Canada has approved the project ( after extensive hearings and consultation), the government of B.C. opposes the project.

This present problem posses significant negative consequences for Canada. There is no question that already the investment climate has taken a hit and this latest Kinder Morgan decision adds to this.

Does the rule of law still apply in this country? Or does the constitution of this country mean what it says in some cases but not in others?

The Province of B.C. cannot have its cake and eat it too. That is, it cannot decide what parts of the constitution with which it agrees and what parts with which it disagrees. Such a position must have consequences.

If this is so then the country, as we know it, is no more.

Hence, the federal government must act for Canada and our constitution. That means B.C. must be brought to heel and the present B.C actions opposing the project must be removed.

Why would anyone invest in this country if the present situation is allowed to continue?

What is most insufferable and hypocritical about the B.C. position is that it uses the environment issue as its main reason for opposition while it approves a Site C hydro project which negatively affects the environment, flooding hundreds of acres of land, supports fossil fuel natural gas exploration (fracking), production and pipeline transmission, and the exploration, production and transmission of the worst fossil fuel, coal.

Brian Peckford, Nanaimo


The views and opinions expressed in this letter to the editor are those of the author and do not reflect the views of Black Press or the Nanaimo News Bulletin. If you have a different view, we encourage you to write to us or contribute to the discussion below.

Just Posted

Crime in Nanaimo leads to ‘explosion’ of interest in Block Watch

Nanaimo and Lantzville area now has more than 100 chapters

Dover Bay Secondary School staging a production of the musical ‘Oliver!’

Attendees are encouraged to bring a non-perishable food donation

Nanaimo council faces taxpayer questions about budget

Preliminary 2019 budget now includes potential tax increase of 5.08 per cent

Winds of up to 90 km/hr forecasted to hit Vancouver Island

Environment Canada is warning that loose objects may cause damage

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Greater understanding needed about importance of new Canadians

There is a lack of understanding of what’s required to move to this country, says letter writer

Nanaimo’s Discontent City being bulldozed

City crews on scene cleaning up, no access to the site allowed

Customers at new Quality Foods finding spare change for Coins for Kids

Charity getting a boost from new bigger, busier Harewood location

Chamber wants to know about Nanaimo’s best Christmas light displays

Greater Nanaimo Chamber of Commerce, News Bulletin partner on Spirit of Christmas Light Up

Out of the doghouse: B.C. city lifts ban on pup who barked too much at dog park

Cameron the Shetland sheepdog is allowed back into Uplands off-leash dog park under some conditions.

No flood of extremist returnees to Canada expected, federal report says

The report says some 190 people with connections to Canada are suspected of terrorist activity abroad

Canada-China relations turn icy over arrest of Chinese exec

The Huawei case has threatened to complicate U.S.-China efforts to resolve a bitter trade dispute.

Prosecutor signs off on former B.C. Liberal government’s quick-wins probe

David Butcher said in a statement released Monday that the RCMP recommended charges under the Elections Act

Canadian physicist who won Nobel Prize touts science for the sake of science

Donna Strickland, 59, said securing the field’s highest honour has given her a significant new platform

Too many die in heavy truck crashes, B.C. auditor says

Province has no mandatory driver training for commercial vehicles

Most Read