Discontent City, a camp for people experiencing homelessness, is being discussed in B.C. Supreme Court in Nanaimo this week as the City of Nanaimo seeks a court injunction against camp occupants. NEWS BULLETIN file photo

Hearing begins to determine fate of Nanaimo’s Discontent City

City of Nanaimo’s legal counsel calls tent city disruptive

Discontent City has become a “vortex” for disruption and criminal behaviour.

That was one of the comments from Troy DeSouza, the City of Nanaimo’s legal counsel, during the first day of a scheduled two-day petition hearing in the Supreme Court of British Columbia.

The city filed a petition earlier this month, seeking a statutory injunction to shut down Discontent City and have its occupants removed from the vacant land at 1 Port Dr., which is located on the corners of Front Street and Esplanade. The petition names Mercedes Courtoreille, Gina Watson, Mike Pindar, Mystie Wintoneak, Kent Sexton, Dean Kory and “other unknown persons” as the respondents.

On Tuesday, Justice Ronald Skolrood heard arguments for and against Discontent City and its very existence at the Nanaimo courthouse, in the first day of a scheduled two-day hearing. There were no city councillors present during the hearing, which took place over five hours.

DeSouza laid out the city’s arguments for an injunction, explaining that many of the residents aren’t homeless, adding that there are youths who have homes who are living at the camp and taking intravenous drugs and prostituting themselves. He said Discontent City has created numerous health, safety, fire, legal and other issues since it was established.

“We are beyond tents now,” DeSouza said.

He said city staff worked hard and were able to arrange funding from B.C. Housing in order to provide more overnight shelter beds to homeless individuals at the First Unitarian Church. He also referenced various affidavits throughout the hearing.

In one instance a woman claims a number of campers were on her property and when she asked them to leave, they called her a “fat old cow” as well as a handful of other profane words, according to DeSouza, who also said that a tent city occupant came to the same woman’s building and “attempted to take” water from her building.

“In our view that is symptomatic of the kinds of disruption that ordinary citizens are facing in their lives and they should not have to face that,” DeSouza said.

However, Skolrood questioned how that a few individuals being rude to a nearby resident was the “fault of tent city.”

DeSouza disagreed, explaining that if tent city weren’t around, there wouldn’t be people stealing water there, nor would there have been an altercation.

“My Lord. They are not allowed to be at tent city. That’s the problem and so what happens is there is a location where they are not even permitted to be and it becomes a vortex of disruption and criminal activity,” DeSouza said.

It wasn’t until the afternoon that Noah Ross, attorney for Discontent City, was able to begin presenting arguments. Ross disputed the claim that the many of the individuals in the camp aren’t truly homeless. He pointed out that the city voted earlier this year against allowing a $7 million affordable housing project in Chase River that was funded by the province.

Ross also said there aren’t enough shelters for everyone, that the ones that do exist aren’t good enough, citing an affidavit from one man who claims he lived at one shelter but left because there were too many rules.

“He says he had to be in by six and could only leave for half an hour and that didn’t accomodate his lifestyle of seeing friends and being out,” Ross said, later explaining that residents at Discontent City feel a sense of community than they don’t have living alone on the street.

The hearing resumes Wednesday, July 18.



nicholas.pescod@nanaimobulletin.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Just Posted

Thief throws rock through window to steal from Nanaimo business

Nanaimo RCMP advise ‘no cash on site’ signs in storefronts

Clippers lose a close one against league-best Vees

Nanaimo falls 4-3 to Penticton in BCHL action at Frank Crane Arena

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Leadership needed on environment

We need to insist that federal parties take a stand on tackling climate change, says letter writer

Thief in Nanaimo steals tablet from vehicle, tries to make online purchases

RCMP remind motorists not to leave valuables in vehicles overnight

RDN grants $1.1 million for replacement of leaky pipes in Cedar

Tender for installation of PVC pipe on Cedar Road area closes Oct. 9

Kids meet machines at diabetes research fundraiser at Nanaimo’s port

Meet a Machine was held Saturday at the Port of Nanaimo

B.C. Lions hype-man marks 15 years of cheers

Crazy P cheers, chants, bangs his drum and spreads a message of love

Island music trivia tournament a hit on World Alzheimer’s Day

More than $13,000 raised by people naming that tune

Festival parade ‘jazzes’ up downtown Nanaimo

Nanaimo International Jazz Festival closes with Laila Biali Trio Sunday

Opposition to 388 Machleary proposal over-extends public hearing

Nanaimo residents 10-1 against development plan in Old City Quarter, public hearing to be continued

Nanaimo Astronomy Society guest will talk about array of antennas

Guest speaker tells about working with 16-kilometre radio observatory in Chile

Nanaimo high school students cut class to attend climate action rally

Extinction Rebellion Nanaimo rally raises awareness, demands action against climate change

PHOTOS: Steller sea lion with plastic around neck rescued on Vancouver Island

Rescue staff determined the plastic band cut the protected animal’s neck approximately two inches

Nanaimo beekeepers take down nest of giant hornets

One nest eradicated at Robins Park, but there are still Asian giant hornets around

Most Read