Previous school plan didn’t measure up

Re: Previous facility plan had considerable merit, Guest Comment, Nov. 3.

To the Editor,

Re: Previous facility plan had considerable merit, Guest Comment, Nov. 3.

It is easy to create simple sound bites (“this board’s decision to scrap an $87-million government-approved facilities plan”), but it takes time and effort to understand the complex issues underneath.

For example, the ministry’s approval merely reflected compliance with their policies and regulations, and did not at all imply a senior level of government’s agreement that one option was superior to another.

Any compliant plan put forward would have received the same approval. It is local representatives that we need to hold accountable for pushing a plan that, while perhaps sound in premise, failed on detail.

To make the plan work, the business case put forward revenue figures that assumed the sale of the complete 14.1-hectare NDSS site. It neglected to account for the cost of replacing the essential district facilities that would have gone with the school, like the District Administration Centre, the maintenance yard and the bus yard.

Neither did it address how far the revenues would have to be adjusted downward if a smaller portion of the site were sold. This is only one of many under-reported flaws that caused responsible trustees to decide that good stewardship required pulling back and starting again.

A facilities plan is supposed to be about creating the best possible learning environment for students.

The district planning document pointed out that the secondary population is highly mobile, as indicated by the 33 per cent of Woodlands catchment students and 40 per cent of John Barsby catchment students who attend other schools.

What is most important in choosing a school site is not its physical location, but the amenities and other advantages it brings with it.

NDSS is a large, flexible site in the heart of the city’s best recreation and sports facilities, and next door to the most important educational institution in the whole region. It is hard to imagine a site likely to produce a better learning environment somewhere else in the city.

Why did this plan want to throw that away?

Elections are time to hold elected representatives to account for their past actions. Reaching blindly for promised money while ignoring inconvenient facts does not look like good stewardship to me.

C. McIvor

Nanaimo

Just Posted

OPINION: Youth advisory council has proven its worth to city

Youth council creates a collective voice, say guest columnists

Editorial: Entrust committees with current city business

New environment committee, for example qualified to discuss current events in city

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: B.C. missing out on ship-building industry

B.C. now losing out on the economic benefit of building ferries, says letter writer

Highland dancer wins North American junior title

Annalise Lam leads Brigadoon Dance Academy contingent in U.S. competition

On Remembrance Day, community pledges never to forget

Images from Remembrance Day ceremonies in Lantzville on Monday, Nov. 11

VIDEO: Don Cherry says he was fired, not sorry for ‘Coach’s Corner’ poppy rant

Cherry denies he was singling out visible minorities with his comments

Report predicts drug resistance likely to kill 400,000 Canadians by 2050

This increase is expected to cost Canada 396,000 lives, $120 billion in hospital expenses

Sportsnet fires Don Cherry after negative comments about immigrants

Don Cherry had said immigrants don’t wear poppies like other Canadians do

Dozens of planes went down on Vancouver Island training for war

Exhibit at Vancouver Island Military Museum depicts dangers of flying B.C. coast during war years

Man seriously injured after shock and fall from electrical tower in Nanaimo

20-year-old was being transported to hospital in Victoria

Trudeau’s new cabinet: Gender parity because it’s 2019? Or due to competence?

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will soon appoint his new cabinet

Canada among three G20 countries least likely to hit emissions targets

It says Canada, South Korea and Australia are the farthest off

Conservatives’ Scheer wants Trudeau to open Parliament Nov. 25

That’s five days after Justin Trudeau is scheduled to swear in a new cabinet

Last remaining Centurion tank from the Korean War makes its journey ‘home’ to B.C.

Tank arrives in B.C. the day before Remembrance Day after a more than 4,500-kilometre transfer

Most Read