Food taboos sometimes worth questioning

In many cases, the reasons for religious food taboos are lost in the mists of history.

Recently a Hindu temple announcement that a local Muslim family had killed a cow and was eating beef led to a lethal mob attack. The meat in the family fridge was goat meat. A commission of inquiry found the crime pre-planned but the ruling Hindu party appears to disagree. State elections were near and there is a practice in India of deliberate violence to stir up religious fanaticism in order to solidify votes through ‘communalism’ or religious hatreds. Indian poet Ashok Vajpeyi said, “The Indian tradition for millennia has been accommodative, open. It is a multi-religious tradition, a multilingual tradition. And that plurality is now being under assault.”

It’s hard to believe that differences in what people choose to eat can lead to the kind of frenzy that justifies open murder. But food taboos, or the deliberate avoidance of a food item for reasons other than simple preference, are unwritten social rules which often defy rational or scientific explanations. For example, the Ache hunters and gatherers of the Paraguayan jungle use only 50 of the hundreds of edible mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians and fish species around them. Only 40 of the myriad plants, fruits, and insects are exploited. Ninety-eight per cent of the calories in the diet of the Ache come from only 17 different food sources.

Why do people cling to inexplicable food taboos? One reason is that a particular behaviour is seen as part of a group’s identity and conveys a sense of belonging. In many cases, the reasons for religious food taboos are lost in the mists of history and over time layers of justifications have settled into unquestioning habit.

In the developed world, eating animals that are considered pets, particularly cats and dogs, is taboo. It can be suggested that pet animals have domesticated humans, in order to lead protected lives. The domestication process has become so entrenched that the pets are regarded as part of the family.

Twenty-five years ago, in a large Indian city, I visited with members of a social change group who would have no truck with unscientific food taboos. Their commitment to community development work was demonstrated by living together with the people they were helping with basic needs as well as skills training and general education. And periodically they would hold beef and pork dinners for their Hindu and Muslim friends. At the time, I thought it a bit cheeky. But today I understand better how they were attempting to remove sources of difference and intolerance by sitting down to eat together without disapproval.

Often I find myself wishing that people who cherish particular food views would be less intolerant of others’ preferences and instead strive together to accomplish food systems that are good for people, animals, plants and general ecological balance. We might be surprised by how much we have in common in that endeavour.

Marjorie Stewart is past chairwoman of the Nanaimo Foodshare Society. She can be reached at

Just Posted

UPDATE: Suspect and Mountie bitten by police dog during arrest south of Nanaimo

Two suspects were arrested in connection with a stolen pickup truck in Cassidy on Thursday evening

City to re-name community policing office and keep it open

Council votes 6-2 for city to maintain a presence at Victoria Crescent office

Nanaimo RCMP seek help finding missing Nanaimo boy

Chaas Mearns, 13, was reported missing Jan. 30

Construction set to begin on Nanaimo airport terminal expansion

First phase of construction project to begin in March or April

Duncan family says care home switched mom’s cat with robot cat

Staff alleged to have said they were taking cat for bath, then replaced her with robotic stuffed toy

VIDEO: Buccaneers double up Generals to win Game 2

Nanaimo now leads the best-of-seven series against Oceanside two games to none

Beefs & Bouquets, Feb. 22

To submit a beef or a bouquet to the Nanaimo News Bulletin, e-mail

More snow forecast to fall Friday on Vancouver Island

Environment Canada calling for 2-10 centimetres on the east coast of the Island and areas inland

VIDEO: Buccaneers double up Generals to win Game 2

Nanaimo now leads the best-of-seven series against Oceanside two games to none

Indigenous elders share history with Nanaimo-Ladysmith School District students

‘Our kids learning their history through elders is nothing that we can find in our textbooks’

UPDATE: One driver taken to hospital after three-vehicle collision in Harewood

Accident happened at Howard Avenue and Seventh Street at about 9:30 a.m.

B.C. ski cross racer wins Olympic gold

Kelowna’s Kelsey Serwa wins the gold medal in thrilling fashion in PyeongChang

New charges against ex-Trump campaign associates

More charges were laid Thursday against President Donald Trump’s former campaign chairman and his business associate

Man accused in death of Winnipeg teen Tina Fontaine not guilty

Raymond Cormier was accused of killing Indigenous 15-year-old and dumping her body in the Red River

Most Read