Lantzville District Hall. (News Bulletin file)

Legal firm clarifies upper and lower Lantzville in water agreement

The District of Lantzville releases a 2016 legal opinion clarifying the definition

The District of Lantzville has released a 2016 legal opinion clarifying the definition of upper and lower Lantzville in relation to the Nanaimo water agreement.

The legal opinion along with a report to council dated September 2016 appeared on the district’s website on Monday following an in-camera council meeting that took place on Oct. 23.

Authored by Devin Buchanan of Fulton and Company LLP and submitted to the district in July 2016, the legal opinion states that the actual definition of upper and lower Lantzville in relation to the water agreement is murky.

It acknowledges that the dividing line for upper and lower Lantzville is generally understood by residents to be Highway 19, but points out that upper and lower Lantzville are defined in the water agreement by a map known as Schedule C, which fails provide any clear illustration defining upper and lower Lantzville.

However, the law firm concluded that it believes Lantzville would be “justified” in using the upper pressure zone as the definition, citing wording in the agreement such as upper Lantzville area, high-pressure zone and low side of the pressure-reducing valve. Although the firm indicated that there is not enough evidence that “positively” supports one definition or another, it believes the intent of the agreement is to supply water to 225 premises located within the existing high-pressure zone.

Buchanan warned that because there could be more than one interpretation of the water agreement, Nanaimo could take the opinion that Lantzville is only entitled to supply water to the area south of the highway and could halt the flow of water to the community.

The firm recommended the district seek an amendment with the City of Nanaimo to clarify the definition of upper and lower Lantzville and receive approval from Nanaimo prior to triggering the agreement.

Coun. John Coulson, who has previously raised concerns about the definition of upper and lower Lantzville, said he’s pleased that the legal opinion was released to the public but has lingering questions about the amount of information that was provided to Fulton and Company LLP by the district. Coulson said he wonders why councillors never bothered to mention anything about clarifying the definition of upper and lower Lantzville when they asked Nanaimo councillors for a series of amendments to the water agreement in June 2016.

“We did that four months previously and there was no mention of upper and lower Lantzville being clarified. Why?” he asked.

Coun. Bob Colclough said there was never doubt in his mind that the language in the agreement refers to pressure zones. He said the decision to release the legal opinion came down to informing the public.

“There is just too much misinformation and misunderstanding,” he said. “Let’s just put it to rest.”

2016 legal opinion by Nanaimo News Bulletin on Scribd


nicholas.pescod@nanaimobulletin.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Lantzville

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Nanaimo United play in a pandemic, win Jackson Cup championship

Div. 1 men defeat Lakehill 2-1 to cap off soccer season after a six-month shutdown

Ride-hailing service nearly ready to start up in Nanaimo

Lucky to Go planning to launch Oct. 1

Nanaimo-North Cowichan MLA Doug Routley seeks reelection

Routley has served as MLA for the area since 2005.

VIJHL season could start Oct. 1, says league president

League awaiting final approval from local health authorities and viaSport

Nanaimo RCMP shut down illegal racing and stunt driving site at Duke Point

Police “swoop in” to seize vehicles and issue violation tickets

B.C. reports 96 new COVID-19 cases, one hospital outbreak

61 people in hospital as summer ends with election

‘Unprecedented’ coalition demands end to B.C. salmon farms

First Nations, commercial fishermen among group calling for action on Cohen recommendations

Earthquake off coast of Washington recorded at 4.1 magnitude

The quake was recorded at a depth of 10 kilometres

B.C.’s top doctor says she’s received abuse, death threats during COVID-19 response

Henry has become a national figure during her time leading B.C.’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic

BC Liberals must change gears from election cynicism, focus on the issues: UBC professors

COVID-19 response and recovery is likely to dominate platforms

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

B.C. could be without a new leader for multiple weeks after Election Day: officials

More than 20K mail-in voting packages were requested within a day of B.C. election being called

Ferry riders say lower fares are what’s most needed to improve service

Provincial government announces findings of public engagement process

City reviewing plans for huge Sandstone project in south Nanaimo

Seacliff Properties says it’s been told to be ready for a public hearing this fall

Most Read